Fans online are already dissecting the timeline, pointing out how Johny claimed to have a longtime girlfriend for three years while still being seen with Chloe and filming 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way around the same period.
The overlap has sparked a wave of speculation, with people trying to figure out who he was actually with and when. The show’s filming schedule, his social media activity, and the way he presented his relationships have all become part of the debate, leaving viewers confused about what was real and what was happening behind the scenes.
His announcement about becoming a first‑time dad only added more fuel to the conversation. Some fans brought up old rumors claiming he had multiple kids in Aruba from different women, tied to his reputation as a flirt in the tourism scene. Because he worked as a pirate‑themed entertainer on tourist boats — constantly around drunk vacationers — people have been repeating the same stories for years, even though none of it has ever been confirmed. Still, the contrast between “first‑time dad” and the long‑running gossip has become a talking point across fan groups.
Chloe hasn’t commented publicly, which many interpret as her choosing not to get dragged into the drama. Some fans think she probably sent a private congratulations just to keep things civil without creating a spectacle. Meanwhile, others are questioning how Johny’s current partner navigated all of this — the overlapping timelines, the dating rumors, the show, and now the baby. With no clear explanations from anyone involved, the whole situation feels tangled, contradictory, and wide open for speculation.
For the latest 90 Day Fiancé news and gossip, don't forget to visit www.90dayfiance-news-and-memes.com. We post daily articles covering all the drama and updates related to both past and current cast members of the show!