Chloe and Johny didn’t even wait for the Tell All to confirm what viewers had already sensed — their relationship ended during filming, and infidelity was at the center of the collapse.
On the show, Chloe explained that Johny had recently switched to a new phone because his old one wasn’t working properly. When he left the old device on the nightstand, she admitted she couldn’t resist checking it, especially since she had long suspected that Johny never fully left his “player” lifestyle behind. His job constantly put him around intoxicated and horny female tourists, and Chloe always feared he was crossing lines behind her back. Her fears were confirmed when she found messages to multiple women — some flirty, others emotional — and the most shocking discovery was that Johny had been messaging a woman who had been contacting Chloe for months, trying to figure out whether Chloe and Johny were serious because *she* had been involved with him too.
When Chloe confronted Johny with the messages from his own phone, the
Aruba native focused less on the infidelity issues and more on why she had touched his device without permission. According to Chloe, he dodged the cheating accusations the same way he allegedly dodged commitment. But the storyline shown on TV was only half the chaos. Last week, Johny went public on social media claiming that production cut scenes where *he* found evidence of Chloe being unfaithful with multiple men. He suggested this was why he never fully trusted her or stayed committed, implying that both sides were hiding things. A screenshot shared by
90 Day Fiancé creator Merrypants showed Johny commenting that Chloe checked his phone but never allowed him to check hers — and when he finally did, he claimed what he found was “way worse” than anything on his device.
Johny also hinted that “everything will come out eventually,” suggesting the Tell All could be explosive. When the season started airing, Johny posted pointed Instagram story quotes about not wasting time or money on women he considered “promiscuous,” and another comparing relationships to buying a used car — comments clearly aimed at Chloe. He implied that despite her being in her early twenties, she had more casual relationships than he was comfortable with, and that this wasn’t a quality he wanted in a long‑term partner. Between Chloe’s accusations, Johny’s counter‑claims, and the scenes production allegedly cut, this breakup is shaping up to be one of the messiest in
90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way history.
